Loading…
Content is loading, please wait.
8.7/ 10
Very good
Recommended without reservation
The clearest luxury/waterfront specialist of this group, backed by Sotheby's global marketing reach and two decades of local closings up to $2.85M.
Pros
- ✓Sotheby's International Realty brand brings global luxury marketing reach to local listings
- ✓Nearly 20 years of local experience with 900+ career closings
- ✓Holds Waterfront Property Specialist and Seller Representative Specialist designations
- ✓Strong five-year production: about $97.6M total value across 207 closed sales
- ✓Comfortable across a wide range — from raw land under $150K to multi-million-dollar lake estates
Cons
- ✗Smallest review count (47) of this group, though still a perfect 5.0 average
- ✗Sotheby's luxury positioning may carry different marketing/fee expectations than a mass-market brokerage
- ✗Solo practitioner — no large team, so responsiveness may vary during peak listing season
Agent overview
Amanda Lumley has sold real estate in the Brainerd Lakes Area since 2006 with Northland Sotheby's International Realty. She's logged more than 900 career closings and roughly $97.6 million in sales volume over the past five years, with Zillow showing a 5.0-star average across 47 reviews.
Core specialties
Waterfront & Luxury Homes
Holds Sotheby's Waterfront Property Specialist designation, with recent listings up to $2.85M on Brainerd Lakes Area waterfront.
Seller Representation
Holds a Seller Representative Specialist designation; five-year data shows a heavier seller-side dollar volume ($58.9M) than buyer-side.
Commission & fees
Not publicly listed; typically negotiable
Who this agent is for
Sellers of higher-end or waterfront homes
Sotheby's global network plus her Waterfront and Seller Representative designations fit move-up and luxury lake-property sellers well.
Buyers of recreational and vacation property
Track record includes land, recreational, and vacation-property transactions across the Brainerd Lakes chains.
Not for
Budget-focused buyers who want an agent whose day-to-day business is concentrated well under $300K — her book skews toward mid-to-upper price points.
Verdict
The go-to boutique/luxury option among this group — best suited to waterfront and higher-end transactions where Sotheby's marketing reach adds real value.
Score: 8.7 / 10 · Very good
Areas served
Common questions about Amanda Lumley
Does Amanda Lumley only handle luxury properties?
No — her recent listings range from under $150,000 land parcels to multi-million-dollar lake estates, though her practice does skew toward mid-to-upper price points.
Is she part of a team?
No — she practices as an individual Sales Associate with Northland Sotheby's International Realty.
Does she work with buyers as well as sellers?
Yes, both, though her five-year transaction data shows a somewhat heavier seller-side dollar volume.