Loading…
Content is loading, please wait.
8.8/ 10
Very good
Recommended without reservation
A Fergus-Falls-born, 18-year RE/MAX veteran with the strongest independently verified review record of any agent in this roundup and back-to-back local 'best of' wins.
Pros
- ✓34 verified RateMyAgent reviews averaging 5.0 stars, plus RateMyAgent's City Winner (Fergus Falls, 2025 and 2026) and County Winner (Otter Tail County, 2025 and 2026) recognitions
- ✓Born and raised in Fergus Falls with 18 years licensed locally
- ✓RE/MAX Hall of Fame, Platinum Club, and 100% Club production honors
- ✓Wide specialty list covering first-time buyers, foreclosure and relocation, farm and investment property, and new construction
- ✓Reviewers specifically cite responsiveness and clear communication through complicated sales
Cons
- ✗Broad generalist specialty list means no single sharply defined niche, unlike some competitors' dedicated luxury or waterfront focus
- ✗'Voted Best Realtor in Otter Tail County' (2024) is a reader's-choice poll result reported in her marketing, not an independently audited award
- ✗Solo practitioner, so availability during a busy listing season depends on one person's schedule
Agent overview
Amanda Armstrong has sold real estate in and around her hometown of Fergus Falls since 2008, working out of RE/MAX Signature Properties. Homes.com credits her with 177 closed sales, 119 of them in Fergus Falls proper, and she has built one of the most consistently reviewed practices in town.
Core specialties
First-Time & Move-Up Buyers
First Time Buyers is listed among her core specialties, and RateMyAgent reviewers specifically credit her with a smooth, supportive process for buyers new to the market.
Rural, Farm & Investment Property
Her specialty list includes Agricultural/Farm Living and Investment Lifestyle property, useful in a market with as much rural and recreational land as in-town housing.
Relocation
Relocation is one of her stated specialties, relevant for buyers moving into Otter Tail County from outside the area.
Commission & fees
Not publicly listed; typically negotiable
Who this agent is for
Buyers who want a hometown guide
Born and raised locally with 18 years in the business, she suits anyone who wants an agent who already knows the neighborhoods, schools, and back roads.
Sellers who value a documented review track record
With 34 verified 5-star RateMyAgent reviews and consecutive local awards, she's a safe pick for sellers who want to see real client feedback before signing.
Not for
Buyers or sellers specifically seeking a dedicated luxury or waterfront specialist rather than a broad local generalist.
Verdict
The best-reviewed generalist in this group with real local roots and two consecutive years of RateMyAgent's local awards – a strong default choice for buyers and sellers who don't need a narrow specialist.
Score: 8.8 / 10 · Very good
Areas served
Common questions about Amanda Armstrong
How is Amanda Armstrong's review record?
RateMyAgent shows 34 verified reviews averaging 5.0 stars, plus back-to-back City Winner (Fergus Falls) and County Winner (Otter Tail County) recognitions for 2025 and 2026.
Does she work with first-time buyers?
Yes – First Time Buyers is one of her listed specialties, alongside Buyer Brokerage more generally.
How long has she worked in Fergus Falls?
She was born and raised in Fergus Falls and has been licensed since 2008, about 18 years as of this writing.