Best Alternatives to Matt Rengstorf

James Kutschat

8.9/10

$53K–$927K · 42 reviews

A well-reviewed broker-owner best suited to lake home, cabin, hunting land or commercial buyers and sellers who want a hands-on, full-time local specialist.

Ryan Hanson

8.8/10

$85K–$1.3M

A licensed-attorney-turned-Realtor who built the highest-volume team in the Fergus Falls lakes market, best suited to buyers and sellers who want a large support team and deep contract expertise behind a lakeshore or commercial deal.

Jay Fletch

8.7/10

$200K–$1.2M · 113 reviews

A 30-year veteran team lead with an unusually deep bench of designations and a genuinely five-star, 100-plus-review track record across the Woodbury/St. Croix Valley corridor.

Ann Jones

8.6/10

$220K–$750K · 28 reviews

A lifelong Shakopee resident running her own small brokerage, backed by an unusually strong 5-star review record for an operation this size.

Marcy Johnson

8.6/10

$70K–$350K

A Hibbing-native broker with 35 years in the business who co-founded her own local firm -- deep tenure, though her individual review count isn't independently verifiable.

Jordan DeCaro

8.5/10

$120K–$700K

Jordan DeCaro is founder and team lead of the DeCaro Real Estate Team, operating under RE/MAX Results out of the brokerage's London Road office in Duluth. A graduate of Duluth Central High School who has held his Minnesota license since 2012, he now leads a roughly six-agent team rather than working solo. RealTrends Verified 2025 data ranks the team first in Duluth by both closed sales volume ($58.41 million) and transaction sides (192). The Duluth News Tribune named him Best Real Estate Agent in 2024, and the team was a 2025 Best of the Midwest finalist for Best Real Estate Agency in the Duluth-Superior-Cloquet area.