Loading…
Content is loading, please wait.Loading…
Content is loading, please wait.Rankings updated July 2026
Stillwater is a community in Washington County. This page tracks the top-rated real-estate agents serving Stillwater — scored on local knowledge, client reviews and market expertise, with zero paid placements. We're completing our agent review for Stillwater now; rankings appear here as each agent clears our editorial bar.
| # | Agent | Score | Focus | Brokerage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Kim Ziton | 9.0 | Luxury | Keller Williams Premier Realty, Luxury Homes Division |
| 2 | Jay Fletch | 8.7 | Relocation | Edina Realty |
| 3 | Jason Gorman | 8.4 | Commercial | Keller Williams Premier Realty |
| 4 | Richard McDonough | 8.2 | Luxury | Lakes Sotheby's International Realty |
| 5 | Kerri DeBaere | 7.9 | Luxury | Lakes Sotheby's International Realty |
$600K–$3.9M
Kim Ziton has worked the Woodbury and east-metro market since the mid-1990s and has been credited by Keller Williams as its top-producing agent in Woodbury every year from 2012 through 2025. She operates as a solo licensed agent supported by an assistant and a staging consultant rather than a multi-agent team, and her publicly listed transactions skew toward move-up and luxury price points above $600,000. Independently verifiable third-party review counts were not accessible at research time, so her public reputation rests more on brokerage production rankings and self-published testimonials than on an outside audit.
$200K–$1.2M · 113 reviews
A 30-year veteran team lead with an unusually deep bench of designations and a genuinely five-star, 100-plus-review track record across the Woodbury/St. Croix Valley corridor.
$200K–$1.2M · 75 reviews
A 30-plus-year Woodbury-office veteran and Keller Williams office owner with a huge career sales record, though his multi-office ownership means you may work with a team member more than with Jason himself.
$370K–$2.4M
Richard McDonough is a fourth-generation Stillwater resident who has worked as a real estate broker in the city for roughly three decades and holds dual licensure in Minnesota and Wisconsin. He practices as an associate broker with Lakes Sotheby's International Realty out of its downtown Stillwater office, with current and recent listings concentrated in the historic Main Street corridor. Third-party transaction data (homes.com) shows 84 closed sales over the past five years worth about $41.9 million; that figure, and the 238 sold listings shown on his own brokerage profile, are both well below the '450+ career transactions' cited in his marketing, a gap that is not explained anywhere public.
$300K+
A Stillwater-based Lakes Sotheby's advisor with a clear, well-documented niche in Woodbury-area luxury sales and senior downsizing — but no public review count to independently verify her volume.
Choosing an agent in Stillwater comes down to the same fundamentals we score across Minnesota: genuine local knowledge of the neighborhood and price point you're targeting, a real track record of recent client reviews, and market expertise in your type of transaction. Favor an agent who concentrates on Washington County over one who lists across the whole metro. See our methodology for how we weigh each factor.